11/19/2025

HOW TO INTRODUCE A JEW TO THE MESSIAH

In the middle of a very busy afternoon the phone rang and the voice on the other end identified herself as the director of a local Christian counseling center. She proceeded to tell me that she was talking to a young Jewish man who had wandered in, and she wondered if I had anything that might be helpful to him.

As I listened to this counseling center director, I immediately thought of a cassette tape I possessed, which contained a teaching entitled “How to Introduce a Jew to the Messiah.” It was by a Messianic rabbi named Manny Brotman who, at that time, pastored a Messianic congregation in Washington, D.C.

I pulled the tape off the shelf and rushed to the counselling center where Elaine, the director, introduced me to the young man. I shook his hand, gave him the tape, and went on my way. It was one event in a very busy day, and I soon forgot about it. Many years later I would learn the significance of that moment.

This was 1980 and Sue and I were pastoring a new congregation in her hometown of Saint John, New Brunswick in eastern Canada. The years went by and 13 years later we were living in Tulsa, OK. During a ministry trip to Ontario, Canada, I preached on a particular Sunday morning in a church pastored by the well-known Canadian evangelist, Bill Prankard.

I preached to a packed-out congregation that morning and after the service a young man came up to me with big smile on his face, stuck out his hand and asked, “Do you remember me?” It was obvious he felt a strong connection with me and I felt somewhat embarrassed that I did not recognize him.

I shook his hand and replied, “I am sorry that I don’t recognize you. What is your name?” He told me his name, and I was even more embarrassed because I did not remember his name. He then asked, “Do you remember giving a young Jewish man a cassette tape in Saint John, New Brunswick years ago?”

It all came back to me and I replied, “Oh yes, I remember.” He said, “That was me and the message on that tape was exactly what I needed to hear.” He went on to say, “I am now pastoring a Messianic congregation in Toronto and I saw an ad in the newspaper where you would be speaking here today.”

At this point he gestured to several rows of people seated near us and said, “Since we had our service yesterday [Saturday], I brought my entire congregation here today to hear you speak.”

I was astounded that day and I am still amazed when I consider how that small seed, which I planted that day, produced such a harvest. It is also a reminder that every Christian should be equipped to "introduce a Jew to the Messiah.”

Manny Brotman’s approach in introducing a Jew to the Messiah was to show the many Old Testament prophecies of a coming Messiah King and how they had all been fulfilled in Jesus. The prophecies are very detailed, predicting the place he would be born, that He would a descendant of David, many details concerning his death, that He would suffer and die for the sins of His people, and that He would rise from the dead.

This was also Paul’s modus operandi for sharing the Gospel with the Jews of his day. Luke describes this in Acts 17:2-3 where he recounts Paul’s ministry in the Jewish synagogue in Thessalonica. He wrote,

Then Paul, as his custom was, went in to them, and for three Sabbath days reasoned with the from the Scriptures, explaining and demonstrating that the Christ had to suffer and rise again from the dead, and saying, “This Jesus whom I preach to you is the Christ.”

Since there was no New Testament at the time, the “Scriptures” Paul is using to make his argument about Jesus are the Old Testament Scriptures. Using persuasive arguments from the Old Testament is how the 1st century church presented the Gospel to the Jewish people.

Sadly, this modus operandi changed as the church became Romanized and gained political power beginning with the Roman emperor, Constantine. With the power of the empire behind her, the medieval church now relied on political force rather than reasonable arguments from Scripture to convert both pagans and Jews.

For example, the Catholic Inquisition targeted Jews and gave them the option of converting to Christianity or being put to death with the sword. The Crusades were military expeditions organized to free the Holy Land from the Muslims. However, in their journeys, these “Christian” crusaders murdered Jews wherever they found them, considering them to be “Christ-killers” and enemies of the gospel.

Such Jew-hatred has been all too common throughout history from those who called themselves “Christian.” Sir John Acton was right when he declared, “Power corrupts; absolute power corrupts absolutely.” This was certainly true of the medieval church which became deeply corrupted with its newfound political power, which had nothing to do with Jesus and the New Testament. Pope Leo should publicly apologize for these atrocities.

These historical atrocities help explain why many Jews today have a mental block towards Christianity. In their minds, Christianity is associated with bigotry, prejudice, and violent oppression. We all have the responsibility of changing this perception by demonstrating by word and deed what true Christianity is all about.

I am convinced that many Jews today can be brought to Christ if we show them the love of the real Christ and present the Gospel to them following the pattern laid out by Manny Brotman and Paul the Apostle—showing them how Jesus fulfilled all the Old Testament Messianic prophecies.

This will have an added benefit for when we become equipped to “introduce a Jew to the Messiah” we will also be equipped to present a profound rational argument for the truthfulness of Scripture and the Gospel message to anyone. This is so because fulfilled prophecy is one of the most powerful pieces of evidence for the accuracy and trustworthiness of Scripture.

Dr. Eddie L. Hyatt is the author of numerous books, including 1726: The Year that Defined America, all available from Amazon and his website at http://eddiehyatt.com.

No comments:

Post a Comment